At 33, I found myself sitting at home on a Saturday Night watching a direct-to-DVD animated adaptation of a Comic Book that I have yet to read, AND I actually found myself getting a little weepy during a few of the dramatic monologues that start to pop up at about 2/3rds of the way into the movie. No, you read that right: direct-to-DVD animated adaptation of a Comic Book. Let that sink into your noodle for a moment or two.
DC has been milking their properties in animated forms for years, so it's not surprising that they have recently taken to doing animated features. It's also not surprising that these are direct-to-DVD; Hollywood is quite forgiving when it comes to superheroes, but on the whole there are a lot of stories that fans want to see that the rest of America would have trouble shelling out for. But why Justice League: The New Frontier? The first feature effort like this was a re-telling of the early '90's Superman / Doomsday story, and the next one is slated to be Batman-centric. But The New Frontier is a strange story, which uses the Cold War / Red Scare paranoia of the mid '50's as a backdrop for a Silver Age Tale that manages to incorporate and / or name check every important character DC ever published. Why this is important might not be exactly obvious at first: the mid '50's were when these characters were first created and introduced. The writer, Darwyn Cooke, uses the actual creation dates to coincide with the dates these characters began adventuring (rather than ignoring time to account for the characters still being young and in their prime in the here-and-now). With me so far?
That, alone, sort of makes this movie a niche market already, and some of the casting probably relegates it to a specific area of Hollywood marketing: Lucy Lawless (Xena: Warrior Princess) is the voice of Wonder Woman; David Boreanaz (Buffy The Vampire Slayer & Angel) is the voice of Green Lantern; Neil Patrick Harris (Spider-Man: The New Animated Series) is the voice of The Flash. It goes on like that. While the casting is sort of big name, most of the actors are already on the Sci-Fi / Comics Convention circuit, and while Brooke Shields does lend her voice for one character, you would be hard-pressed to say that Carol Ferris (the daughter of the Ferris Aircraft President, Carl Ferris) is, exactly, a "major character" in the DC Universe. (And for those playing at home: five points for those who said, "She's Green Lantern's love interest for much of the initial run of the GL Series.")
I will admit, I'm a Silver Age junkie. While I was initially reared on Comics from the later '70's and early '80's, I contend that the influence of the Silver Age had not yet worn off by the time I started reading, and more to the point, the Silver Age was the foundation of the stories I was obsessed with. Sure, I would start out with a contemporary issue of Green Lantern when I was a kid, but it wasn't long before they start referencing back-issues, and you have to track down these old stories to put the new ones in context. Being a Comics reader is as much research as it is enthusiasm for the characters you currently love, and it wasn't long before I could re-count every origin of any character I cared about, and would go on to detail their adventures (as best as I knew them) up to "present day."
Writers of Comics are aware of this, and there was always an Easter Egg of some kind in any new issue: a reference to a character from another book, or the hint that two characters were someone connected in a way that neither of them were aware of. The Silver Age, more than anything, took the idea of a Shared Universe (introduced with the Justice Society of America in the '40's), and expanded it to a point where every word and image of every issue was laden with a kind of intertextuality that evoked the whole while still being immediately relevant to the story at hand. I would argue that why I loved comics had more to do with the Universe these characters adventured within more than it had to do with individual characters that I knew and loved.
The New Frontier is exactly what people like me love: milking the idea of a Shared Universe in a new way that is simultaneously familiar and completely original. Darwyn Cooke, more than a writer, is clearly a fan. He cares about these characters and these ideas, and when it comes to exploring how the proto-Justice League first formed, he writes with his heart as much as anything else. However, this particular movie moves me in a way that the previous and the proceeding one probably won't, for one simple reason: Green Lantern.
It is no secret that he is, and has been, my favorite character since I started reading Comics, and for most of my teenaged years I not only obsessively read GL stories, but spent hours imagining what happened between stories. There was no aspect of his character I was unfamiliar with, no tale about him that I did not know, and I could drop logic about Hal (or any of the thousands of GLs in the Universe) in a way that probably terrified my family. When I wasn't avoiding chores, thumbing through back-issues, or thinking about girls, I was trying to imagine what it would be like to have a Power Ring, flying through space, on my way to save the Universe. Superman & Batman were cool, sure, but until there was a Green Lantern Movie, nothing in spadex from Hollywood would ever really pique my interest.
Now, at 33, my wish has finally come true. Not only is Green Lantern a founding member of the Justice League, but New Frontier gives so much screen time to the character that we see him fighting in the Korean War, we see him get his first test pilot gig, and (AND!) we get to see his Secret Origin! This is the stuff of my formative years, endlessly imagining how these moments that were crystallized in my mind would come together on Screen. How can this not bring a tear to my eyes?
While it's hard to recommend this to anyone who doesn't know about 50 years of DC Comics Continuity (or, at least, someone who can find a paraphrased version thereof, complete with a character index for easy reference), I can say that it is not just the emotional attachment that is causing me to love it. The animation is really beautiful, the cast (as mentioned above) are professionals that really get into the characters, and the writing is above average for anything related to the Justice League (at least, since the Giffen run that ended in the mid-'90's). Plus: it's fun. Superman wears his old costume, Wonder Woman shows us her dark and creepy side, and we get to see some great Noir-ish moments with The Martian Manhunter as he tries to remain inconspicuous as an average Police Detective in a world constantly looking for scapegoats. In a way, Darwyn foregrounds the real-world influences that led the original writers to creating these characters, and by incorporating those elements into the narratives, he makes the characters richer and our experience as readers much more vivid.
Of course, you have to also come to terms with the fact that the person recommending it is admitting to spending a Saturday Night getting all emo over an direct-to-DVD animated adaptation of a Comic Book. While that's not exactly a barometer to measure the average person's reaction to something like this, it's probably something you should consider nonetheless. And if you can look past that, well then, perhaps I've found a new best friend.